Loyalty cards have become a popular way for grocery stores to reward frequent shoppers with discounts, deals, and personalized savings. But are they really worth it, or are they just another marketing tool? Many shoppers sign up, scan, and hope for the best, but the actual benefits can vary wildly. This article explores which grocery store loyalty programs genuinely help you save money and which ones might just be collecting your data. We’ll break down the value behind six major programs, then wrap up with a clear conclusion. Here’s what you need to know before swiping that loyalty card again.
1. Kroger Plus Card: Personalized and Powerful
Kroger’s loyalty card consistently ranks among the most valuable for shoppers. Users get access to weekly digital coupons, exclusive sales, and fuel points with every purchase. The app also allows you to track spending and tailor coupons based on past purchases. Customers often save 10–20% off their total bill when they shop strategically with the card. Fuel savings are especially strong—earning 10 cents off per gallon for every $100 spent. Overall, the Kroger Plus Card delivers a strong return for frequent shoppers.
2. Safeway for U: Rewards You Can Stack
Photo by Tara Clark on Unsplash
Safeway for U offers a modern rewards program that’s easy to use and packed with value. Members earn points for every dollar spent, which can be redeemed for groceries or fuel discounts. You also get personalized deals based on your purchase history. One standout feature is the ability to stack manufacturer coupons with store savings. Digital freebies like a birthday treat or a monthly item boost its appeal. For families shopping weekly, Safeway for U can result in serious savings over time.
3. Walmart Rewards: Better Online Than In-Store
Walmart doesn’t have a traditional loyalty card, but its Walmart+ membership includes some savings perks. Members can earn Walmart Rewards when shopping online or through the app, which can be applied to future purchases. The annual fee is $98, which might be a downside for some shoppers. However, the program includes free shipping, gas discounts, and even streaming benefits through Paramount+. In-store shoppers won’t get as much out of it unless they frequently use the app. It’s more of a hybrid membership than a pure loyalty program, but it has value for the right person.
4. Target Circle: Solid Savings With No Cost
Target Circle is a free rewards program with real value built in. Shoppers get 1% back on eligible purchases to redeem later, along with access to weekly deals. Exclusive coupons and offers are customized based on your shopping habits. You also receive a birthday discount and early access to special promotions. The app makes it easy to activate deals before checkout, making savings quick and simple. While it’s not as aggressive as some grocery programs, it’s still a worthwhile option for regular Target customers.
5. Publix Club: Best for Digital Deals and Prescriptions
Publix doesn’t offer fuel rewards, but its loyalty program still shines in specific areas. Club Publix members get personalized digital coupons, sneak peeks at new sales, and exclusive BOGO alerts. It’s also great for prescription discounts, which can help families with ongoing medical costs. While the savings may not be dramatic at the register, consistent users notice savings add up. The app and online portal make clipping and saving easy for all ages. For regional shoppers in the Southeast, Publix Club is a must-have.
6. ALDI and Trader Joe’s: No Card Needed, Just Low Prices
ALDI and Trader Joe’s take a different route—offering everyday low prices with no loyalty cards at all. Their philosophy is simple: keep prices low for everyone rather than providing exclusive discounts to members. While this approach doesn’t provide personalized deals or coupons, it does mean transparent pricing. ALDI in particular keeps costs down by limiting brands and streamlining operations. Fans of either store rarely miss loyalty cards due to consistent affordability. If you’re looking for savings without the hassle, these stores deliver.
Which Card Should You Choose?
When it comes to saving money, not all grocery loyalty cards are created equal. Kroger and Safeway stand out for frequent shoppers who want maximum savings and fuel perks. Target and Publix offer solid, low-commitment options for casual users. Walmart+ can pay off if you shop online frequently, but it may not be ideal for in-store-only customers. Meanwhile, stores like ALDI and Trader Joe’s prove you don’t need a card to get great prices. Choosing the right program depends on your shopping habits, but with the right fit, loyalty cards can help stretch every dollar.
Read More
Why Your Grocery Store’s Loyalty Program Is Secretly Costing You Money
